VST Testing Methodology

1. Preparing for Testing

Before testing begins, we set up a controlled environment to ensure reliable results:

  • Identify Plugin Type: Synthesizer, effect, or utility. Understanding the plugin’s purpose allows us to tailor our testing approach.

  • DAW and System Setup: We test across multiple DAWs and operating systems, using professional hardware, accurate monitoring, and a variety of sample rates and bit depths.

  • Test Material: Synths are evaluated with full-range MIDI sequences and velocity layers. Effects are tested using diverse audio stems, including drums, bass, vocals, and full mixes.

We make sure the plugin works as intended in a variety of scenarios:

  • Preset and Loading Checks: Factory presets are tested for accuracy and reliability.

  • Parameter Response: All controls are verified for smooth operation and proper automation response.

  • MIDI and Sidechain Testing: Synths are tested for MIDI mapping, velocity response, and modulation, while effects are checked for correct sidechain routing.

Sound is our main focus:

  • Tonal Accuracy: We check whether the plugin’s output is clear, rich, and free of artifacts.

  • Dynamic Range and Transparency: Compressors, limiters, and EQs are evaluated for coloration and fidelity.

  • Frequency Response and Stereo Imaging: We analyze consistency across frequencies and ensure stereo effects are phase-accurate.

We test the plugin under stress to ensure reliability:

  • CPU and Memory Usage: Light and heavy patches are evaluated.

  • Latency: Both DAW-reported and audible latency are measured.

  • Stress Testing: Multiple instances, extreme modulation, and high polyphony are tested to detect any instability or crashes.

A plugin should be intuitive and easy to use:

  • GUI and Layout: Controls are logically arranged, labels and meters are clear.

  • Workflow: We evaluate preset management, randomization, undo/redo, and documentation accessibility.

Plugins are tested to ensure they work across platforms:

  • DAWs: VST2, VST3, AU, and AAX formats

  • Operating Systems: Windows 10/11 and macOS (Intel & Apple Silicon)

  • Bit Depth and Sample Rate: Evaluated across different session settings to ensure consistency

Each plugin receives a detailed report including:

				
					| Category                | Score (1–10) | Observations / Issues | Suggested Improvements | Priority (Low/Med/High) |
|-------------------------|--------------|---------------------|----------------------|-------------------------|
| Feature Clarity         |              |                     |                      |                         |
| Parameter Control       |              |                     |                      |                         |
| Usability               |              |                     |                      |                         |
| Stability               |              |                     |                      |                         |
| CPU Usage               |              |                     |                      |                         |
| Overall Recommendation  | Accept / Marginal / Reject |       |                      |                         |

The report may also include audio examples demonstrating plugin performance under various conditions.

For more thorough evaluations, we may also perform:

  • Blind testing to reduce bias

  • A/B comparisons with reference plugins

  • Extreme scenario testing, such as unusual sample rates, complex MIDI input, or chained instances

Shopping Cart